The kinetics of the reactions of bis-acceptor-substituted benzyl anions (PhCXY^–, X,Y = CN, CO₂Et, COPh, SO₂Ph) with benzhydrylium ions and quinone methides (reference electrophiles) have been determined in dimethyl sulfoxide solution at 20 °C. The reactions follow second-order kinetics, first order with respect to the electrophile and first order with respect to the carbanion. The addition of 18-crown-6 ether, which efficiently coordinates to the anions' counter ions K⁺, did not affect the kinetics, which indicates that the measured rate constants refer to the reactivities of the nonpaired carbanions. Comparison with the reactivities of the structurally analogous secondary carbanions HCXY^– shows that replacement of H at the carbanionic center by Ph reduces the nucleophilic reactivities towards a reference benzhydrylium ion by factors in the range of only 1.2 (X,Y = SO₂Ph) to 6 (X,Y = CO₂Et). The plots of lg k₂ versus the electrophilicity parameters E of the reference electrophiles are linear, thereby indicating that the correlation lg k₂(20 °C) = s_N(E + N), which characterizes nucleophiles by the two solvent-dependent parameters s_N and N and electrophiles by the parameter E, is applicable. In this way, it becomes possible to integrate these carbanions into our comprehensive nucleophilicity scale, which provides a direct comparison of the nucleophilic reactivities of different families of compounds.